Guest Post: Traditional Publishing vs. Self-Publishing

23 July 2012

As a part of her book tour for Only a Novel, the lovely Amy Dashwood has agreed to make a stop at Literary Lane and chat about the wonderful world of Publishing — while drinking tea, of course, because it just wouldn't be Literary Lane without that.

Hello everyone! Elizabeth has very kindly invited me to guest post on her blog today, and I’m thrilled and honored to be here.

On June 21, 2012, I self-published my very first novel through CreateSpace, an affiliate.  (More information about the book, Only a Novel, can be found at the end of this post.)  It was the end of a long, fun but arduous process that began in November of 2011.  And today I am here to talk about the experience of self-publishing.  Do me a favor and don’t fall asleep, okay? I promise to try and make it interesting.

When I first heard about self-publishing, my initial reaction was, “Oh, that’s nice… but when I write books, I want to publish them for real.”  I think that may be most people’s viewpoint on self-publishing, and I am here today to say that self-publishing IS for real.

I don’t claim to be any sort of an expert, but it seems to me that there are three main reasons why people shy away from self-publishing.

1. Your work is not reviewed by an agent or a publisher, and you don’t get accepted or rejected.
2. Your book won’t appear in bookstores unless you make arrangements yourself for this to happen (and that’s not an easy thing to do).  In the same vein, you won’t get to do book signings unless you organize those yourself too, and so you miss out on all the free chocolate running around at book signings.  (There is free chocolate at book signings… right?  Don’t disillusion me if there isn’t.)
3. You have to do all the formatting, proofreading and editing yourself (unless you hire someone to do it for you, which can be really expensive).

Like I said, I ain't no expert, nor do I claim to have all the answers, but I do love to debate, so I have a ready argument for each of those three points. Let's start with number one.  (For obvious reasons.) With self-publishing, you have the freedom to publish what you like without worrying about rejection from a publisher who wants nothing more than to make money.  No, you aren't getting an acceptance letter from a big-name company-- but why, exactly, is that so special?  I'm not trying to sound cynical here, but when you think about it... who really cares what a publishing house thinks? Are you writing to please a publishing house, or to please your Savior, your loved ones and yourself?  (And hey, I'm not saying that publishing a book through a traditional publisher is a bad thing-- not at all.  I'm just saying that it's not the only option!) About book signings-- again, this is one of those "are you seeking praise or just writing because you love it?" things.  Book signings aren't bad.  Book signings are fun! And there's chocolate!  (That is, having never been to one, I can only assume that they are fun and that there is chocolate.  Again, don't disillusion me.)  But we don't write because we dream of book signings, do we?  We write because it's in our blood.  (Although if you do write only because you dream of book signings, then by all means churn out a book about vampires, make a gazillion dollars and have fun at your book signings.  Only don't expect me to ever speak to you again if you write a book about vampires.) 

Proofreading, editing, and formatting, however... well, on this note I can't be quite as upbeat.  The simple truth is that these things are a pain in the upper-vertebrae-and-laryngeal-tubes.  Formatting will cause you to want to tear your hair out when you realize that the margins on every other page are off, editing will give you an overpowering urge to pull the computer's plug and go take a nap and proofreading has been proven to reduce your creative capacity by 87.3 percent.  (We have not yet determined who has proven this fact, but once we do, we'll let you know.)  But there is one ray of light shining through the pages and pages of glaring text, and that is that you're doing this exactly the way you want to.  You get to pick the font, you get to choose how the pages will be numbered (top or bottom? corners or middles? that is the question) and you get to design the cover image. You're completely in control of your book... it's a deliriously delicious feeling. In fact, the whole experience could be described as deliriously delicious.  In a nutshell, self-publishing enables you to get a jump start on your writing journey, and though there are headaches involved, it's so worth it.  And even if you don't get book-signing chocolate along the way, you'll survive.  Plus, you'll be at a lower risk for diabetes.  Yay!

* * *

Yet Another Period Drama BlogMiss Amy Dashwood is a daughter of the King of Kings, a homeschooled seventeen-year-old and a lover of books, period dramas, chocolate, long bike rides, babies, teacups, historical costumes and fiddle music.  Only a Novel, her first full-length work of fiction, chronicles a year in the life of Elizabeth Markette, a young woman with a head full of books who takes on a job as a governess after the death of her grandmother.  Only a Novel is available for purchase on Amazon, and you can find Amy at either of her two blogs, Yet Another Period Drama Blog and The Quest for Stories.

3 epistles:

  1. WONDERFUL! I really enjoyed this, and it was just what I needed to hear! One question expensive is self-publishing, or more in particular, CreateSpace?

    Thank you, Miss Dashwood and Elizabeth Rose! I totally agree with you, Miss Dashwood.

    -A Fellow writer,


  2. A very interesting post.I have been shy of self publishing for a few reasons. Not everything that is self published is really all that good(though I have come across a few books that I would very much like to read that are self published. *Looks at Violets are blue*). I think being afraid that not something is really not very good is my real fear. It is an interesting option, and thank you for the post! I have been wanting to write a book, or books, for a while, almost my whole life. I have a start to one. I think a reason I want to write books is to be able to reach out to people in the future. I know for me is is a really amazing feeling to read a book written by someone, to read their thoughts on life, issues of their day, and so many other things. I want to be able to reach out to people in that same way, to show they what I think, what I feel, what my opinion is through a story.

    Writing is such an amazing tool and I feel that at many time I am not at all a master of such great tool that God has given us.


"Gracious words are like a honeycomb; sweetness to the soul and health to the body." —Proverbs 16:24

Related Posts with Thumbnails